Northern Renaissance

Art Objects

Story Behind the Painting – Ep. 12 – Haywain by Hieronymus Bosch

By MUZEA April 4, 2026

In the twelfth episode of The Story Behind the Painting, we dive into one of the most prophetic and “juicy” works in art history: The Haywain Triptych by the Flemish master Hieronymus Bosch.

Painted in the late 1480s—the same era as Botticelli’s optimistic Birth of Venus—Bosch offers a starkly different, pessimistic vision. While Botticelli celebrated the revival of classical beauty, Bosch was issuing a grim warning about a world descending into materialism, hedonism, and spiritual decay [06:46].

A Three-Act Drama of the Human Condition

As a triptych, The Haywain is designed to be read like a map of historical and spiritual choices, moving from left to right:

The Left Panel (The Origins): This panel depicts the Garden of Eden, but Bosch focuses on the fall from grace. He shows the descent of rebel angels from the sky and the pivotal moment humanity turns away from paradise [01:14]. This is the “why”—the beginning of the struggle.
The Center Panel (The Present): This is the titular Haywain. It is a chaotic, crowded space representing the current state of the world, where everyone is obsessed with the temporary and the material [01:34].
The Right Panel (The Aftermath): The future. Bosch’s vision of hell isn’t just fire; it’s an industrial scene of shadow and construction. Strange figures build a fortress to house those who lost themselves in the chaos of the center panel [01:49].

The Symbolism of Hay: The Value of Dust

To a 15th-century viewer, the metaphor was clear. A popular proverb of the time stated: “The world is a haystack; everyone takes what they can grab.” [02:13].

Hay is the ultimate symbol of materialism: it is common, fragile, and eventually turns to dust. It has no lasting value. Yet, in Bosch’s center panel, we see a massive wagon of hay being swarmed by humanity. Figures are caught under the heavy wheels, so focused on grabbing a handful of grass that they don’t notice the harm they cause to those around them [02:52].

The Irony of Leadership and Distraction

While commoners fight on the ground, high-ranking officials and leaders follow behind on horseback. They believe they are in control of the cart because they already “own” the hay [03:14].

However, the true irony lies in what is actually pulling the wagon. It isn’t horses; it’s a pack of strange, hybrid demonic creatures leading the entire parade straight into the hellscape of the final panel [03:30].

On top of the haystack, a small figure looks toward the sky, hoping for a better path. But right next to them, a figure in blue plays a melody on a flute, distracting everyone from their ultimate destination [03:45]. This “blue flute player” is the 15th-century equivalent of modern digital distractions—the “blue light” of our smartphones serenading us as we roll toward the edge [08:32].

The Dawn of Global Greed and the Lisbon Connection

To understand Bosch’s frantic energy, we must look at the shifting world around him. He lived during the “sunset of the Middle Ages,” as early capitalism began to sweep away steady traditions [04:11].

The Rise of Banking: The Fugger family, the world’s first true global bankers, were building an empire that funded emperors and popes alike [04:47].
The Road to India: Lisbon had become the most important warehouse on the planet after unlocking the maritime path to India [05:11]. Fugger-financed copper was moved from Antwerp to Lisbon and then loaded onto Portuguese fleets bound for the East [05:19].

Bosch saw these maritime discoveries not just as engineering feats, but as a dangerous expansion of a sinful world. He was terrified that if humanity hadn’t fixed its “internal rot”—its greed and individualism—all we were doing was exporting our hell to the rest of the planet [10:52].

A Mirror for the Modern World

The episode draws striking parallels between Bosch’s 15th-century nightmares and our modern landscape. The “creed of hedonism” Bosch depicted is visible today in societal structures that idolize power and possession above all else [07:34].

The scandals of figures like Jeffrey Epstein, Harvey Weinstein, or P. Diddy are described as “The Haywain in real time”—the result of a world where “having” is the ultimate religion [07:49].

Why King Philip II Loved the Nightmare

Interestingly, there isn’t just one Haywain; there are two. One resides in the Museo del Prado and the other at the Escorial Palace [09:13]. Both were acquired by King Philip II of Spain, the most powerful man in the world at the time. He kept these nightmare paintings in his private quarters as a grim meditation on the burden of power and the thin line between a kingdom and a catastrophe [09:46].

Looking Up

Ultimately, Bosch’s message is that the choice remains an individual one. Despite the corruption of the powerful or the distractions of the “flute player,” we still have the ability to look up at the light instead of down at the grass [08:58].

Check Full Episode here:

Keep Reading

Art Objects

Story Behinf the Painting – Ep. 10 – Portinari Altar by Hugo van der Goes

By MUZEA April 3, 2026

In the heart of the Galleria degli Uffizi in Florence, amidst the sun-drenched frescoes and elegant tempera panels of the Italian masters, sits a monumental work that feels like a cold, brilliant wind from the North. Spanning a staggering six meters in width, the Portinari Altar is more than just a painting; it is a bridge between two worlds.

In the tenth episode of The Story Behind the Painting, we explore the “Northern Shadows” cast by this masterpiece and the troubled genius of its creator, the Flemish master Hugo van der Goes.

A Secret Weapon: The Flemish Oil Technique

When the Portinari Altar arrived in Florence in 1483, it didn’t just impress the local artists—it stunned them. At a time when Italian masters were still largely perfecting egg tempera, Van der Goes arrived with a “secret weapon”: oil paint on large oak panels [01:46].

By utilizing linseed and walnut oils, Hugo could apply paint in translucent glazes. This technique allowed for a level of hyper-realism and depth that fresco simply couldn’t match. Notice the deep lapis lazuli of the Virgin Mary’s robe and the glowing crimson of the angels [02:08]; they seem to emit light from within, an optical effect that changed the course of Florentine art forever.

The Banker’s Legacy and a Nautical Odyssey

The painting exists because of the ambition of Tommaso Portinari, a shrewd Italian banker representing the Medici Bank in Bruges. Portinari wanted a monument to cement his legacy in both his adopted northern home and his native Florence [02:47].

The journey of the altarpiece was a 15th-century logistical miracle. Because of its immense weight and the fragility of the oak, it couldn’t be hauled over the Alps. Instead, it traveled by sea, sailing from the North Sea, around Spain, and into the Mediterranean [03:10]. When it finally reached Florence on May 28, 1483, it took 16 porters to carry the heavy crates to the high altar of the church of San Egidio [03:38].

A Nativity Drenched in Symbolism

While Italian versions of the Nativity—like those by Botticelli—often feel airy and celebratory, Van der Goes presents a scene of heavy tension and stark realism [04:05].

The Virgin Mary: She is not a radiant young mother but a somber figure. Her hands are joined in a prayer that looks like a plea, and her robe is a blue so deep it borders on black—the color of mourning [04:16]. Even at her son’s birth, she contemplates his eventual death.
The Infant Christ: Christ does not lie in a soft manger. Following the visions of St. Bridget of Sweden, he lies naked on the cold, hard earth [04:50]. This symbolizes his humility and his role as the “bread of life” fallen to earth.
The Flowers: In the foreground, two vases of flowers act as a theological map. The scarlet lily represents the blood of the Passion, while the white and blue irises symbolize purity and the “Seven Sorrows” of the Virgin [07:47].
The Architecture: Behind the scene, a shattered Romanesque building represents the “Old Law” crumbling to make way for the “New Law” brought by Christ [06:54].

The Rugged Realism of the Shepherds

One of the most revolutionary aspects of the Portinari Altar is the depiction of the shepherds. In Italian art, these figures were often idealized. Van der Goes, however, painted them as rugged, weathered men with calloused hands and gaps in their teeth [08:24].

There is a frantic, almost breathless energy in their faces—a psychological realism that was entirely new to the history of art [10:33]. They represent the common people, captured with a “disastrous realism” that shocked 15th-century viewers.

Hugo van der Goes: The Original Troubled Genius

To understand the intensity of the painting, one must understand the man who painted it. Hugo van der Goes was a titan of his era, serving as the dean of the Ghent Guild of St. Luke and managing lavish decorations for the Burgundian court [09:11].

Yet, at the height of his fame in 1477, he walked away from worldly success to enter the Red Cloister monastery near Brussels [09:38]. Despite his religious devotion, Hugo struggled with a profound spiritual desolation often called “melancholy.”

The chronicles of his fellow monk, Gaspar Ofhuys, provide a moving account of Hugo’s later years. He suffered from a deep conviction of his own unworthiness, fueled by the pressure to perfect the Portinari Altar and the conflict between his artistic pride and his humble faith [11:19]. Long before Vincent van Gogh, Hugo was the original “troubled genius,” a man whose creative fire was inextricably linked to his emotional depth.

An Enduring Legacy

The Portinari Altar was a “lightning bolt” for Florence [12:10]. Masters like Ghirlandaio and even a young Leonardo da Vinci studied its textures and its use of light. It remains a painting of profound contradictions:

A celebration of birth that whispers of death.
A display of immense wealth commissioned by a banker, centered on a child lying on the cold, hard ground.

Today, it stands in the Uffizi as a testament to the soul of an artist who poured the entire weight of the human experience into every brushstroke [12:02].

For more deep dives into the world’s most iconic masterpieces, watch the full episode on the

Keep Reading

Art Objects

Story Behind The Painting – Ep. 9 – Hours of Mary of Burgundy

By MUZEA April 3, 2026

Imagine holding a device in the late 1470s that could transport you from a quiet, candlelit room into the soaring, silver-lit nave of a massive Gothic cathedral. It’s not a headset or a screen; it’s a book. Specifically, it’s the Hours of Mary of Burgundy, a masterpiece of Flemish illumination that the latest episode of Story Behind the Painting by MUZEA describes as the “virtual reality” of the 15th century.

The Window Miniature: A Visual Revolution

The centerpiece of this episode is the “window miniature,” a painting so advanced it feels like a trick of the eye—or more accurately, a trompe l’oeil [02:38].

The painting depicts a woman, Mary of Burgundy, sitting by a window and reading her prayer book. But as you look through that window, you see a second version of Mary, kneeling before the Virgin and Child inside a cathedral [02:22]. This is “simultaneous reality” [03:32]:

The Physical Mary: Sits in the “now,” touching her prayer beads and reading.
The Spiritual Mary: Exists inside the sacred vision she is reading about.

The artist uses linear perspective to pull the viewer’s eye into the depths of the cathedral, creating a sense of infinite space on a piece of vellum smaller than a standard iPad screen [01:49]. By treating the page’s edge as a physical windowsill, the artist turns flat parchment into a three-dimensional portal.

The Woman Behind the Book: The Most Sought-After Bachelorette

Mary of Burgundy was far from a fragile princess. At just 20 years old, she became the Duchess of Burgundy after her father, Charles the Bold, was killed in battle [05:02]. At the time, Burgundy was a “middle kingdom” stretching from Switzerland to the North Sea, controlling trade and cloth production—making it the wealthiest court in Europe [04:16].

Mary faced immense pressure from King Louis XI of France (known as the “Universal Spider” for his webs of lies), who tried to seize her lands and force her into marriage [05:17]. Amidst this chaos, this prayer book served as her private sanctuary.

Interestingly, Mary was also a vibrant athlete. She was a master of falconry, an expert equestrian, and loved ice skating on the frozen canals of Flanders [06:06]. Tragically, it was her love of the outdoors that led to her end; she died at just 25 after a horse-riding accident during a falcon hunt [06:41].

The Anonymous Master: The “Banksy” of the 1470s

The genius behind this work remains a mystery. Known only as the Vienna Master of Mary of Burgundy, this anonymous Flemish illuminator was a revolutionary [07:22].

Before his influence, medieval book illustrations were beautiful but flat. The Master introduced:

Trompe l’oeil Borders: He painted jewelry, glass vases, and flowers with realistic shadows so they appeared to sit on top of the page [08:05].
Atmospheric Perspective: He showed how light and air make distant objects paler and less sharp, as seen in the cool, silver light of the cathedral interior [08:22].
Introspective Emotion: Unlike the stiff symbols of previous eras, Mary’s face shows a quiet, pensive depth—a human soul in a moment of private reflection [08:40].

A Legacy of Light and Space

The Master of Mary of Burgundy was the founder of the Gent-Bruges School, the foremost center for manuscript illumination in Europe [09:01]. His techniques paved the way for the grand landscape paintings of the High Renaissance. Without his “window concept,” the shift from symbolic medieval art to the realistic perspective of the Renaissance might have looked very different.

When you look at this miniature, you aren’t just looking at a Duchess; you are looking at the ghost of a woman who was brave, athletic, and visionary, frozen forever in a moment where the material world ends and the divine imagination begins [04:07].

Explore the miniature in detail:

Keep Reading

Art Objects

Story Behind the Painting – EP. 6 – Melun Diptych by Jean Fouquet’s

By MUZEA April 3, 2026

If you stumbled across the right panel of the Melun Diptych without context, you might assume it was a modern CGI render, a surrealist fever dream from the 1920s, or perhaps a high-fashion editorial. The Virgin Mary is startlingly pale, her hairline is plucked back to another zip code, and she sports a perfectly spherical, exposed breast.

But this isn’t modern art. It was painted in 1452 by Jean Fouquet, and it remains one of the most provocative, unhinged, and “messy” devotional paintings in history.

The Power Player: Etienne Chevalier

To understand this painting, we first have to meet the man who paid for it: Etienne Chevalier. In the 1450s, Etienne was the “CFO of France”—the royal treasurer for King Charles VII. A self-made man who rose through the ranks, he was described as incorruptible, trustworthy, and so close to the king that he was the executor of the royal will [03:00].

Etienne commissioned this diptych to hang over his wife’s tomb in the Church of Notre-Dame in Melun. In the left panel, we see Etienne himself in a permanent state of prayer. Standing behind him is his namesake, St. Stephen (Etienne in French).

St. Stephen is dressed as a deacon in stunning blue robes, but he’s carrying a gruesome “signature accessory”: a jagged, bloodstained stone resting on a book [03:25]. As the first Christian martyr, Stephen was stoned to death, and in medieval art, saints always carry the instruments of their demise like a grim fashion statement.

The Scandalous Madonna: Agnès Sorel

The right panel is where things get “spicy.” While the diptych was meant to honor Etienne’s late wife, the Virgin Mary looks nothing like her.

Art historians have long held an “open secret”: the model for the Virgin is believed to be Agnès Sorel, the “Lady of Beauty” and the official mistress of King Charles VII [04:13]. Etienne wasn’t just the king’s treasurer; he was one of Agnès’s closest friends.

By commissioning a painting where the king’s mistress is depicted as the Mother of God, Etienne was pulling off the ultimate 15th-century “flex.” He was signaling his proximity to power, his grief for a lost friend, and his hope for a VIP pass to heaven by knowing the right people. It’s a bizarre mix of humble devotion and high-society blasphemy [05:01].

The Artist from the Future: Jean Fouquet

If the Melun Diptych feels like it’s from another dimension, it’s because Jean Fouquet was an artist ahead of his time. Around 1446, Fouquet did a “study abroad” trip to Italy [05:37]. He was one of the few French painters of his era to study Italian linear perspective and 3D volume, even painting a portrait of Pope Eugenius IV while in Rome.

Fouquet was also a master miniaturist, accustomed to looking at the world through a magnifying glass. He used a technique involving melted glass (enamel) to give his work a high-gloss, high-definition finish that looks like a 4K screen [06:14].

The result is the Uncanny Valley. Look at the angels surrounding Mary: they aren’t soft or fluffy. They are monochromatic, bright red cherubim and blue seraphim that look like polished plastic figurines [07:08]. Fouquet used geometry and lighting in a robotic, supernatural way to create a high-fashion atmosphere that felt more like a “liminal space” than a traditional church.

A Long-Distance Tragedy

Today, the Melun Diptych is a victim of a “historical divorce.” During the French Revolution, the two halves were ripped apart. The left panel (the “boys”) now lives in Berlin, while the right panel (the “queen”) lives in Antwerp [07:48].

Scientists used dendrochronology (tree-ring dating) to prove the two panels are “soulmates”—both were cut from the exact same oak tree felled in 1446 [07:59]. Though they belong together, they haven’t shared a room in centuries.

The World’s First Selfie

Fouquet knew he was the “GOAT” (Greatest of All Time). He didn’t just paint the diptych; he signed it with a tiny enamel medallion of himself [08:18]. This is considered the oldest signed self-portrait in Western art history. He wanted the world to remember the name: Johes Fouquet.

The Melun Diptych serves as a reminder that people in the 1400s were just as obsessed with status, celebrity, and “aesthetic” as we are today. Next time you think your social media feed is too curated, just remember that Etienne Chevalier spent his life savings to be remembered forever standing next to the king’s mistress in a blue-and-red fever dream.

Stay curious. Stay messy.

Watch the full episode on MUZEA:

Keep Reading

Art Objects

Story Behind the Painting – EP. 3 – The Arnolfini Portrait by Jan van Eyck’s

By MUZEA April 3, 2026

In the mid-15th century, the city of Bruges was the commercial beating heart of Northern Europe. It was a place where Russian furs, Venetian silks, and Spanish oranges collided in a vibrant display of global trade. In this world of rising merchant power, few objects capture the era’s opulence and mystery quite like Jan van Eyck’s 1434 masterpiece, The Arnolfini Portrait (also known as The Arnolfini Marriage).

In the third episode of Story Behind the Painting, we peel back the layers of this iconic oil painting to discover that what looks like a simple wedding portrait is actually a complex legal document, a high-stakes “flex” of wealth, and a masterpiece of Northern Renaissance detail.

The Best of the Best: A Statement of Power

To understand the weight of this painting, one must first look at the artist. Jan van Eyck was the court painter for the Valois dukes of Burgundy—the highest tier of artistic prestige at the time. For the merchant Giovanni di Nicolao Arnolfini and his wife to hire him was a massive statement [03:33]. It was the 15th-century equivalent of a tech CEO hiring a celebrity photographer usually reserved for royalty.

While the Italian Renaissance focused on human physiology and muscles, the Northern Renaissance, led by competitors like Robert Campin and Jan van Eyck, was obsessed with the context and surroundings [02:40]. Every object in the room was placed there with intent.

Subtle Flexing: Oranges, Fur, and Blue Silk

The Arnolfini couple didn’t just want to show they were rich; they wanted to show they were connected.

The Blue Textile: The bride’s gown features a vibrant blue, a color that was incredibly expensive and often reserved for royalty [05:22].
The Oranges: On the windowsill and chest sit fresh oranges. In 1434 Bruges, these were exotic luxuries imported from Spain or Portugal, costing a fortune to keep fresh [05:29].
Excessive Fabric: The bride’s gown is heavy with swathes of extra material. This wasn’t just fashion; it was a sign that they could afford not only the cloth but the servants required to carry and maintain such a cumbersome garment [07:16].
The Fur: Both garments are trimmed with expensive furs like mink and sable. Giovanni’s robe is cut to calf-length, signaling he is a “man of action” who needs to move freely for his business [08:44].

The Mystery of the Left Hand: A “Morganatic” Marriage?

One of the most debated details is the way the couple holds hands. Giovanni is offering his left hand, not his right [12:33].

This suggests a “Morganatic marriage” or a “left-hand marriage.” In 15th-century society, this usually occurred when a man of high status married a woman from a lower social class. This type of union came with two strict conditions for the bride [15:55]:

She and her future children relinquished all inheritance rights to the husband’s noble estate.
Her children would not continue the noble family lineage.

In exchange, she was guaranteed financial security if she became a widow. This painting, therefore, likely served as a visual matrimonial contract, documenting the terms of their union in an age before formal church marriage certificates were mandatory [15:12].

The Convex Mirror: A Window to the Artist

At the center of the painting hangs a curved, convex mirror—a technological marvel of the time. Producing a flat mirror was nearly impossible; instead, glassblowers would blow a sphere, coat the inside with mercury and tin, and then cut out a circular section [11:12].

If you look closely at the mirror’s frame, it is decorated with ten tiny medallions depicting the Passion of Christ [11:47]. But even more striking is the reflection itself. In the mirror, you can see two figures entering the room. Above the mirror, Van Eyck wrote in elaborate Latin script: “Johannes de Eyck fuit hic”—Jan van Eyck was here [12:14].

This wasn’t just a signature; it was a legal testimony. He was acting as a witness to the marriage contract, a role that would later inspire other great painters like Velázquez in his work Las Meninas [18:22].

Symbols of the Soul

Beyond the wealth and law, the painting is filled with spiritual and domestic symbols:

The Dog: A small Brussels Griffon sits at the couple’s feet, symbolizing fidelity and a nurturing home environment [09:46].
The Shoes: Removed and placed to the side, the discarded clogs suggest that the couple is standing on “holy ground,” as marriage was considered a sacred sacrament [09:06].
The Single Candle: One lit candle in the chandelier during the daytime is often interpreted as the all-seeing eye of God or the presence of the Holy Spirit witnessing the union.

Conclusion

The Arnolfini Portrait is a testament to the power of the Northern Renaissance. It shows a world where art was used as a tool for social positioning, legal protection, and religious devotion. Today, it hangs in the National Gallery in London, continuing to fascinate viewers with its “inception-like” details and the silent testimony of a painter who was “there” nearly 600 years ago.

Watch the full episode here:

Keep Reading

Art Objects

Story Behind the Painting – EP. 2 – Mérode Altarpiece by Robert Campin

By MUZEA April 3, 2026

In the modern world, we “flex” our success through designer clothes, high-end smartphones, or luxury travel. In the 15th century, however, the ultimate status symbol wasn’t a car—it was a commissioned painting. But as the latest episode of Story Behind the Painting reveals, the Mérode Altarpiece (or the Annunciation Triptych) by Robert Campin was more than just a display of wealth; it was a complex blend of marketing, domestic prayer, and revolutionary artistic detail.

The Ultimate Textile Flex

Unlike most grand altarpieces of the era, this work wasn’t commissioned by a priest for a cathedral. Instead, it was paid for by a wealthy merchant, likely from the Inghelbrecht family (identified by the coat of arms in the window) [01:39].

Because the client made his fortune in textiles, the painting is essentially a high-end advertisement for his business. Look closely at the robes of the Angel Gabriel and the Virgin Mary—the fabric is heavy, voluminous, and folded with such precision that it dominates the frame. By showcasing such “finesse” in the rendering of cloth, the merchant was subtly promoting the quality of his own wares [01:20].

A Home for the Holy

The Mérode Altarpiece was designed as a home altar. Measuring roughly two feet tall, it was intended for private devotion in a middle-class Dutch home [01:54]. The owners would kneel before it to pray to Mary, often asking for the blessing of children.

What makes this painting a masterpiece of the Northern Renaissance is its setting. While Italian artists were obsessed with the idealized human body and mathematical perspective, Northern artists like Campin focused on hyper-realistic textures and domestic interiors. Through the use of oil paint, Campin captured:

The rust on iron nails [03:30].
The delicate feathers of an angel’s wings.
Double shadows cast on the walls, suggesting two light sources—the window and the open door—a level of “ray tracing” that was centuries ahead of its time [05:41].

Hidden Symbols in Every Corner

The central panel depicts the Annunciation—the moment Gabriel tells Mary she will bear the Son of God. But Campin strips away the traditional golden halos to make the figures feel more human and accessible [05:07]. Instead, holiness is signaled through everyday objects:

The Tiny Jesus: Look for a small figure carrying a cross flying through the window on seven beams of light [05:25].
Purity Symbols: The white lilies, the clean white towel, and the polished water pot all represent Mary’s virginity.
The Extinguished Candle: A thin wisp of smoke rises from a candle that was just blown out. Some suggest this represents the moment the Divine enters the physical world, 혹은 perhaps a draft from the open door [06:08].

Joseph and the Mouse Traps

The right panel features Joseph in his workshop, and it contains one of the most famous “Easter eggs” in art history: mouse traps [06:54]. One sits on his workbench, and another is displayed on the window ledge outside.

While some theologians argue the trap symbolizes Christ as the “bait” to catch the devil, there’s a more practical theory related to the time. The 15th century was still reeling from the Black Plague, which people knew was carried by rats. By showing Joseph making mouse traps, the painting portrays him as a provider and a protector—keeping the home safe from both physical disease and spiritual evil [07:37].

The World Outside the Window

While the interior feels peaceful, the world outside was anything but. The 15th century was defined by the Hundred Years’ War, English occupations, and civil unrest in cities like Paris and Ghent [02:46]. This painting offers a rare, idealized glimpse of peaceful Dutch streets, contrasting the chaos of the era with the eternal calm of the divine [02:39].

A Modern Twist

The episode concludes with a playful “updated” version of the triptych created by AI. In this modern reimagining, the holy family lives in a cramped apartment (due to the housing crisis), Joseph is a software engineer protecting the home from cyber attacks, and the angel Gabriel might have a hard time fitting through the small windows [09:46]!

Whether viewed in the 1400s or through a digital lens today, the Mérode Altarpiece remains a testament to the power of detail and the enduring intersection of the sacred and the mundane.

Watch the full analysis here:

Keep Reading